next up previous
Next: 4. Closing of Up: Tonguesbottles, and disconnected Previous: 2. Opening Magnetic

3. The Magnetic Field Magnitude Catastrophe

In the absence of some mitigating processes, the outward expansion of CMEs would cause the number of open field lines, and hence IMF magnitude, to grow without bound. This ``magnetic field magnitude catastrophe'' was first pointed out by Gosling [1975]. The amount of open magnetic field in interplanetary space has been examined most recently using an improved proxy, the ``total flux integral'' which combines the scalar inward- and outward-pointing fluxes and removes the effects of variations in the solar wind speed in determining the amount of magnetic field crossing 1 AU [ McComas et al., 1992a]. If we assume that all counterstreaming electron events represent simply connected magnetic tongues (B in Figure 2), then for CME rates characteristic of solar maximum, the field magnitude at 1 AU would double over 9 months in the absence of any mitigating processes. If CMEs remain magnetically attached but are flux ropes, where field lines can loop around many times in interplanetary space before connecting back to the Sun, then the rate of build-up would be smaller. However, it must be stressed that if CMEs retain any attachment to the Sun whatsoever, the field magnitude catastrophe will ultimately occur in the absence of some other process to close off previously open fields.

The average magnitude of the IMF displays 50% variation from the mid-1970s to the mid-1980s [ Slavin et al., 1986] while the total flux integral displays 60% variation [ McComas et al., 1992a,b]; both show basically the same modulation over the solar cycle with maxima shortly after solar maximum and minima shortly after solar minimum [ McComas et al., 1992a,b; McComas, 1994]. Both this variation over the solar cycle and the fact that the field magnitude does not display unbridled growth, indicate that in addition to CMEs opening new, previously closed field regions from the corona into interplanetary space, there must be some process for closing off previously open field regions and returning magnetic field lines to the Sun.



next up previous
Next: 4. Closing of Up: Tonguesbottles, and disconnected Previous: 2. Opening Magnetic



U.S. National Report to IUGG, 1991-1994
Rev. Geophys. Vol. 33 Suppl., © 1995 American Geophysical Union